Neither.

neither

I have to choose between those two?
Would still rather Vice City.

^This.
But San Andreas if I'm stuck with those two. =\

GTA San Andreas old school

SA

Tough decision :/

San Andreas! Claaaassic.

GTA4: It got some 10/10s
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Theft_Auto_IV

SA. VIce City's my fave though.

gta4 because its the only one i have played :P

SA. VIce City's my fave though.

San Andreas. I have yet to try GTA IV, though, so my answer is a bit biased.

San Andreas

san andraes is biiig and you can swim. But eather one is good. TA 4 has a great story.. so doe SA.. but SA lets you mess around with flying more.... But i like GTA4 more

neither lol

both!

GTA4 !

Also try getting Undead nightmare pack for Red Dead Redemption . Played it and it's very good !

Mmm, pile of burning members....the flames feed my pet Balrog. :-P

Probably neither because they thought Vice or an earlier one was better.

If they prefer Sonic, should they be TRIPLE executed? :D

Neither. :P Carmageddon.

SA was much bigger and had more cool stuff to do. I was kind of disappointed that they trimmed the features in GTA4. It's still an excellent game, but I had more fun in SA.

GTA3... sorry i just had so much fun with that game back in the days.

Actually i never really liked the driving physics of GTA4 the car seems to glide and fly rather than been driven.

San Andreas

I didn't really like either. ^^ But probably GTA4

Yet simple but complex to consider, I am going with SA. I have not playing both yet.

SA

IV sucked ass IMO

Borring....
No me gustan esos juegos.

Neither. GTA sucks.

San adreas

GTA 4 more. There the only 2 games i like in the seris

San Andreas, I mean, don't get me wrong, I loved playing IV, but San Andreas has a much longer storyline which keeps me wanting to play for days.

GTA 4

neither

4 is fun I have it, apparently has lots of expansions.. haven't gotten those yet.. dunno.

Seriously, what is up with GTA IV? I bought it I think at least a year ago, but my PC couldn't handle it. Just bought a new one, but that whole Windows Live and Rockstar Club thing just isn't working. I never manage to get into the game, it freezes beforehand, or there is a problem with the Rockstar club, or with Windows Live...

Since I can't get it to work at all, obviously I have to go with San Andreas.

San Andreas

San Andreas.

GTA 4 was ok, and I could cope with the story and its DLC.

Though San Andreas is the only GTA, by far, that has the most customization in any GTA game. From Cars to clothes. I remember playing that game long after beating it (2-3 years) on my PS2

Memories...

Though, GTA 4's graphics were ok, I just wish more were done to it.

(PC versions are another story. I love both)

Ninguno, odio ese juego. =P

San andreas is the best one! :D *bricked*

I'd say Saints Row 2, its similar, but doesn't take itself seriously, so its actually funny.

Either, but 4 is just my opinion.

I guess San Andreas...But man, I love me some Vice City! XD

Neither. Don't care for GTA

neither

Neither, Simpsons Hit & Run. A fair bit of the same action, like the driving missions and crap...plus the Simpsons, minus most of the language, most of the violence, and all of the prostitution. Which, don't get me wrong, can be welcome in the right place...but mah gaming is not it. Besides...GTA doesn't let you run over Patty and Selma :D

Tough call. GTA$ is nice for the (somewhat) realistic aspects, but in terms of replay-ability and over-the-top fun, I'd definitely have to go with SA.

Don't ask me, I've only played GTA4.

GTA 4 ^_^

This is a trick journal, because it is a command not a question.

Not such an easy question. :P
SA is more colourful, and more in keeping with GTA's tounge in cheeck attitude. and it has tons of variaty.
4 on the other paw has more of a realistic vibe, but in doing that it feels less funny. But it has better physics and more of a sense of control for Niko (like the ability to pick stuff up)

I'd say go for what style appeals to you as both have very engrossing and fun storys.

none....
those games are all the same T____T

San Andreas.

GTA IV

GTA San Andreas

IV

Vice City.

:p

GTA4

I thought San Andreas was much more fun. GTA4 had more flash thanks to the advanced technology, but San Andreas had better gameplay.

I should add, though, if you're asking because you want to know what to buy, and you decide on GTA4, check and see if Grand Theft Auto IV: The Complete Edition is available in your part of the world, and if not, when it will be. It just launched in the US for Xbox 360 and PS3, and only costs $40 US. For that, you get the entire original game PLUS the two add-on packs, The Lost and The Damned and The Ballad of Gay Tony. If you bought the game when it originally launched and the two add-on packs separately, it would have cost $100 US.

san andreas por siempre

SA.

4 and Vice both sucked from trying too damn hard.