Gale the wizard from Harvest Moon: Animal Parade. I was originally going to marry Jin, but then I saw this guy...

He kind of slightly reminds me of someone.

Anyways, here's what gifts you should give him and gifts you shouldn't give him:

Best Gifts:

Fugue Mushroom

Hot Coffee

Shining Coffee Beans

Shining Ground Coffee

Coffee Ice Cream

Shining Tea Leaves

Pontana Root

Crystal accessories

Good Gifts:

Green Tea

Herb Tea

Cafe au Lait

Coffee Candy

Perfect Coffee Beans

Strawberry Ice Cream

Mint Ice Cream

Tea Ice Cream

Crystal, Aquamarine, Sapphire

Shining Cocoa Fruit

Shining Milk

Bad Gifts:

Junk

Failed recipes

Octopus

Salted Octopus

Squid