I wanted to create a little beauty and joy in textual form. Did I succeed?
Poetigress does a Thursday Prompt every week. This one was "festival." You can join in, too! Just go to http://www.furaffinity.net/journal/1838552/
Poetigress does a Thursday Prompt every week. This one was "festival." You can join in, too! Just go to http://www.furaffinity.net/journal/1838552/
Category Story / Fantasy
Species Unspecified / Any
Size 120 x 120px
File Size 6.9 kB
I'm not sure I phrased it well, perhaps a better way to put it is that some of the individual details made it hard to follow. Everything taken as a additive whole suggests a solid story line, but taken individually some of the paragraphs seem a little fragmented with details / imagery that I didn't fit. However, this could just be because I'm unfamiliar with your story line - I know a lot of my stuff comes out really unclear because I often forget that 90% of my material is still in my head and no where else.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not attempting to be overly critical; not do I make any pretenses of actually having the credibility to make serious critique. I just try to offer an honest opinion as often as I can, because I know they can be hard to come upon as a writer here.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not attempting to be overly critical; not do I make any pretenses of actually having the credibility to make serious critique. I just try to offer an honest opinion as often as I can, because I know they can be hard to come upon as a writer here.
Upon further consideration, I decided I might be succumbing to tunnel-vision; so I re-read for a fresh perspective - And I must say that it read much better the second time through, after I already knew the basic storyline. It seems you were going for a more diffuse and atmospheric feel that was, as a result, more description-heavy that I was expecting.
Personally, I don't like to submit in .txt because the text shows up before your description. In visual work (which this site is heavily geared towards), it isn't as big a problem, but I think you'd be hard-pressed to find someone who scrolls down through all that writing to read your description before the main piece. So, especially in the instance of a more non-traditional piece like this, the reader goes through the whole thing and THEN reads the description and puts everything together - thus the perceived fragmentation I quoted earlier. Putting everything in the description box give you the option to type in your description ahead of the story itself - Take a look at how Panzergulo submits, he does it brilliantly.
Personally, I don't like to submit in .txt because the text shows up before your description. In visual work (which this site is heavily geared towards), it isn't as big a problem, but I think you'd be hard-pressed to find someone who scrolls down through all that writing to read your description before the main piece. So, especially in the instance of a more non-traditional piece like this, the reader goes through the whole thing and THEN reads the description and puts everything together - thus the perceived fragmentation I quoted earlier. Putting everything in the description box give you the option to type in your description ahead of the story itself - Take a look at how Panzergulo submits, he does it brilliantly.
FA+

Comments