A MASSIVE improvement over the years. This is very good! O.O

Man you improved a lot in the last 10 years :3

Something grew on you :u

a real glow up as they say

I wouldn't say it "degraded", rather changed - obviously.
If the artist welcomes any constructive critiques, I would say the 2021 version's tail, hips (lovely hips!), thighs, feet, arms, facial elements like nose, ears, hair - and so on - apparently improved, not to mention the body's anatomy and the clothing.
What I like to point out on the 2021 version is either her eye looks too big, or her forehead is a bit short - comparing to the 2011 version's head, which looks more proportionate to me.

Well, huge breasts are another table, some people love it, some don't. I prefer smaller breasts with reaaally nice buttocks. :) But that's only a matter of taste, it doesn't affect the artwork in any bad way. Keep up the good work!

I think I have to agree that, while the body has improved massively over the years, the face has not.
Specifically the eye, it's size and placement just feels off.

Overall it's an improvement, but the eye size and placement needs some attention.
I say this as constructive criticism to the artist more than anything.

Your skill certainly has increased! Awesome work.

the one on the left 100% is better

ok i duno if i will be the only one but i actually think the older version is way better.
Why?
- in the never version the boobs seem to be "abnormal" big. Like "Not fitting" size-big. There is no problem if a character has a bigger boob size but those doesnt look quite right.
- The face seems off. I duno how or why but it looks WAY to off in the 2021 version. Like, the old face there is small, cute, a bit teaseful even. The never version is way to big and has no real "charisma" to it.

I mean im sure it should look like an improvment but it seems for me actually like that the older version is actually the better one since it looks more natural and cute t me than the newer version...Im just honest here, no offense ^^;

who..who left the comment end deleted it? :o

thats all up to you and of course totally your choice. what we try(ied) is only to help you. Its up to you if you take the help or not.

She got thicc, in all the right ways~

So cool to see these! You've definitely improved, more defined anatomical details, better cloth details, and improved hands and feet.

Going to be one of those outliers and say the left looks more appealing than the right.

I can't offer much helpful input for an artist, not an artist myself nor an art enthusiast, but this is the best I can give:

The facial features--eye(s), snout/jaw to say the least--compared to the old is off putting of how exaggerated it is. The old one I find cute and adorable, the new one I don't even know how to absorb it...

The drastic change in the breast is another thing, but that's most likely just my taste changing as I get older. Fair to say the anti-gravity breasts is no longer in my interest, but besides that the drastic change in size of them is what bothers me the most.

I showed this to a few friends and they're confused of what's going on with the legs in the new one--I think I see what they mean. Like that "concave" on the leg (that's horizontal on the bed) in the new one is very wide and deep, while the old one is more narrow and shallow (respectively), and more close to how it proportionally looks.

One said something about the "loss of detail on the tail", upon asking for clarification I was given this: "Attention was paid to fur direction earlier on. It just degraded to 'I'll put a triangle here, and one here, and one here...' in the second." (Hopefully someone else understands what he means.) However he had more issue with the face and legs than the tail.

Usually with comparisons of old & new, the artist stays more close to how it looked but in their current style compared to how they drew x years ago, and that involves keeping the proportions as close as possible to the original with the change of art style. There's defiantly a change in proportions...

Old head had very bad proportions, very small face who not follow of the style what i wanted to see back then, that's why new has bigger size of face (i no wanna draw doll's size head)
Breast pushed by bra, if you still ignore underwear. Also in past i didn't draw proper size what i want to see.
With leg have some question, but old one totally have no volumetric feeling, together with shitty shading.
Old tail had many sharp edges-fur which it's also out of style, however, new also need some corrections.

I'm stays on style! (based on Tailsrulz's 2007-2010) and improvements. But never on a shitty, unproportional anatomy, with shitty shading and colors.
In 2011 i only started, without practice, without tuttorials, without help, without good proggram, without fixed style of my, using reference and without tablet.
And i still not use help, references and tutorials because i came to style what i always wanted to draw.

I like the new one better.

Clearly you show massive improvement in style and detail, though I prefer them smaller-breasted, like your older version. Outside of that, I've been happy to follow your work since I first found it, shortly after I first came to FA.

i see your love of large breasts has grown with your artistic skill. haha.
there are things to like about both, but overall this remake is a stylistic improvement.

Ну я прям даже и не знаю, что здесь не так

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachme.....6622/image.png