Well as the title says, please critique this
this is my new style :3 but before I get to excited about it, I want people to tell me if the anatomy is correct and if it looks realistic enough in this style ^ ^
Feel free to be as harsh as you want. Just don't be rude or I will bite your head of.
^ ^ well critique away
(if this turns out okay, this will be Kirov's body structure ^ ^)
this is my new style :3 but before I get to excited about it, I want people to tell me if the anatomy is correct and if it looks realistic enough in this style ^ ^
Feel free to be as harsh as you want. Just don't be rude or I will bite your head of.
^ ^ well critique away
(if this turns out okay, this will be Kirov's body structure ^ ^)
Category Artwork (Digital) / Animal related (non-anthro)
Species Wolf
Size 894 x 894px
File Size 75.8 kB
k, I edited it.
http://darknoctem.deviantart.com/gallery/#/d2we34f
look better? or is the eye still wrong?
http://darknoctem.deviantart.com/gallery/#/d2we34f
look better? or is the eye still wrong?
Found this image, might help what I mean.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:G.....f_P1130275.jpg
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:G.....f_P1130275.jpg
I usually don't go all critique-heavy on people, but I saw this on the front page and saw you were asking for critique, so...
I'm not an expert on wolves, but I think the legs look really nice. The front legs/paws are my favorite part, so I'd say you should keep that as it is. (I don't know your "normal" style, though. XD; I'm just commenting on what I see here.) I think the muzzle looks a biiiit thick for a wolf; they have longer and narrower muzzles than dogs. (I don't know this specific character, though, so if that was done on purpose, then it's fine.) And, as a last note, the head and neck ruff look a little large to me compared to the size of the body.
Still love those front paws, though, holy crap. =D (And please keep in mind this was just me going off what looks right; I didn't Google a picture of a wolf or anything to look at. I'm not an expert on canine anatomy, either, so if someone tells you something that conflicts with what I said, then you might wanna go with their opinion. XD; )
I'm not an expert on wolves, but I think the legs look really nice. The front legs/paws are my favorite part, so I'd say you should keep that as it is. (I don't know your "normal" style, though. XD; I'm just commenting on what I see here.) I think the muzzle looks a biiiit thick for a wolf; they have longer and narrower muzzles than dogs. (I don't know this specific character, though, so if that was done on purpose, then it's fine.) And, as a last note, the head and neck ruff look a little large to me compared to the size of the body.
Still love those front paws, though, holy crap. =D (And please keep in mind this was just me going off what looks right; I didn't Google a picture of a wolf or anything to look at. I'm not an expert on canine anatomy, either, so if someone tells you something that conflicts with what I said, then you might wanna go with their opinion. XD; )
lol thanks for the crit xD
I edited it http://darknoctem.deviantart.com/gallery/#/d2we34f look better?
I edited it http://darknoctem.deviantart.com/gallery/#/d2we34f look better?
Yeah, although I'd still make the muzzle skinnier, myself. XD Like I said, I'm not an expert.
Also~ I see some other people have said the eye looks weird, but...I actually prefer the eyes in the original version. Maybe the edited version is more realistic, but the eye on the verison posted here just looks better to me. Sometimes you have to choose between what looks good and what is super realistic. It depends on how realistic a style you want. And that part's up to you, since I don't know. XD
Also~ I see some other people have said the eye looks weird, but...I actually prefer the eyes in the original version. Maybe the edited version is more realistic, but the eye on the verison posted here just looks better to me. Sometimes you have to choose between what looks good and what is super realistic. It depends on how realistic a style you want. And that part's up to you, since I don't know. XD
The body is good, but the head does not seem right. The ears are at an odd angle, and the muzzle and eye are not right. The eye is too pointed...should be more rounded. The ear closest to the viewer is backwards pointing on the inside. The muzzle is too straight and the forehead is too sharply angled. I don't think the tongue hanging out is quite right either...
Good start, especially on the body.
Good start, especially on the body.
K, I edited it http://darknoctem.deviantart.com/gallery/#/d2we34f look better :)
I think that's the right pose for a wolf.
http://fc02.deviantart.net/fs16/f/2.....g_by_Elruu.gif
http://fc02.deviantart.net/fs16/f/2.....g_by_Elruu.gif
FA+

Comments