If I write fiction where Theseus and the minotaur fall in love
And then someone else takes my fic, swaps out the labyrinth for a coffeeshop setting
And then someone swaps the minotaur for another monster
And then someone swaps Theseus for another hero
Is it still the same ship?
And then someone else takes my fic, swaps out the labyrinth for a coffeeshop setting
And then someone swaps the minotaur for another monster
And then someone swaps Theseus for another hero
Is it still the same ship?
Category All / All
Species Unspecified / Any
Size 650 x 487px
File Size 176.8 kB
Well no, because while the allegorical ship of Theseus may change out all it's component parts and still, debatably, remain the same thing, this definition of ship is defined by the parts.
A more interesting question may be if the ship between, say, the Hades version of Theseus and Asterius remains the same ship after it's been passed through to an audience of people who have only heard of the characters through fanfic.
A more interesting question may be if the ship between, say, the Hades version of Theseus and Asterius remains the same ship after it's been passed through to an audience of people who have only heard of the characters through fanfic.
It depends on how they use the thread rope.
I don't think it's the same fic; with a sailing vessel, the parts and their relative locations remain roughly the same - the execution between these shipwrights is similar enough to match what was there previously, resulting in the final vessel . With romantic stories, however, the execution varies - sometimes lightly, sometimes heavily - between members of that class of shipwright.
Also? Excellent pun.
I don't think it's the same fic; with a sailing vessel, the parts and their relative locations remain roughly the same - the execution between these shipwrights is similar enough to match what was there previously, resulting in the final vessel . With romantic stories, however, the execution varies - sometimes lightly, sometimes heavily - between members of that class of shipwright.
Also? Excellent pun.
FA+

Comments