Can only state based on personal prefs, I like the one on the left much better. Mostly that one's head and face is more natural to me like the way she always has, May want to keep the eyebrows a bit more modest like the left. The one on the right looks a little too much like Spice (Not saying there's anything wrong with Spice!) or someone else I think because of the facial style, Hard to put my finger on why I think it looks that way. Also prefer the lighter outline of the eyes on the left. May think of more in time.

This is most helpful, thank you. :)

You welcome! Overall, Avoid over humanizing, Still should look Mobian based, She's always had that perfect balance between those elements with her body!