Here is another minor antagonist from Eli's Wonderful Life. Catano Arno is a cat who was friends with Eli until Shad convinced him that Eli was a bad person. Catano even falsely claimed that he never liked Eli and had always hated him, but Eli knew that this wasn't true. Catano's line, "I was never Eli's friend" is proven to be a lie when Eli saw that in an alternate timeline where Shad was never born, Catano never betrayed Eli. While the other friends that late permanently betrayed Eli reformed at least once before the permanent betrayal, Catano didn't reform at all. Making him the most gullible of the people who believed Shad's lies.