I get it, I really do.
You spend all night sketching and inking the most perfect linework on that red panda.
It comes time to color, and you're not gonna just cover up all that pretty linework with black fur right?
So what's the harm in using dark brown.. or brown. Or tan. Or cream. Fuck it, just use whatever colors you want, right?
I realize I'm making something serious out of something supposed to be fun but, Christ, when does the line drawn on blatant inaccuracy for the sake of.. I'm guessing ego or lack of creativity?
Inb4 character choices, anatomy clarity, artistic choices, wimbly wombly anyone can do anything they want liberal bullshit, or any other excuses.
You spend all night sketching and inking the most perfect linework on that red panda.
It comes time to color, and you're not gonna just cover up all that pretty linework with black fur right?
So what's the harm in using dark brown.. or brown. Or tan. Or cream. Fuck it, just use whatever colors you want, right?
I realize I'm making something serious out of something supposed to be fun but, Christ, when does the line drawn on blatant inaccuracy for the sake of.. I'm guessing ego or lack of creativity?
Inb4 character choices, anatomy clarity, artistic choices, wimbly wombly anyone can do anything they want liberal bullshit, or any other excuses.
Category All / All
Species Red Panda
Size 1280 x 762px
File Size 198.9 kB
This isn't coming from a place of authority so much as noticing a large swath of artists either copping out for the sake of their linework, not researching the actual animal, nor challenging themselves to work with black/colorless fur. Very rarely does this arise from the owner of the character's choices.
People are just translating the back to the everything.
They see the dark fur and think "That must just be a shadow" mentally.
Folks very frequently go by (faulty) memory rather than reference. This is why ... well.... almost everything.
There are tons of Furry-isms in art, from coloration to anatomy. You could be making these for a while.
They see the dark fur and think "That must just be a shadow" mentally.
Folks very frequently go by (faulty) memory rather than reference. This is why ... well.... almost everything.
There are tons of Furry-isms in art, from coloration to anatomy. You could be making these for a while.
By that logic, you shouldn't complain if the artist starts your tails coming out of the side your neck, because they're "already broken" anyway. ;)
Yours is a cross between full anatomical physiological accuracy and fiction. One to Two does not in any way move the base of the tail(s). And the misplaced base happens with one, too.
Also, I'm not advocating for 100% accuracy. On plantigrades especially, that would just be weird. See http://forums.furaffinity.net/threa...../#post-1802218 for a good example. The downside is the number of artists who do the very-wrong third one. o.o
Yours is a cross between full anatomical physiological accuracy and fiction. One to Two does not in any way move the base of the tail(s). And the misplaced base happens with one, too.
Also, I'm not advocating for 100% accuracy. On plantigrades especially, that would just be weird. See http://forums.furaffinity.net/threa...../#post-1802218 for a good example. The downside is the number of artists who do the very-wrong third one. o.o
My observation was that tails should go in a proper place and a lot of people put them in very-broken places.
Your reply was that you have two tails, so that counts as broken.
I pointed out that there's a difference between artistic license and artistic error, and that if broken positioning is defended with two tails being broken as well, then you may as well defend any level of broken with any intentional style decision.
So, just pointing out that "what about...?" is not a defense for a problem, and that there are differences in inaccuracies, where some inaccuracies are fine (these are anthro animals after all) whereas others are just broken despite the artist and character creator not intending it to be broken.
Overall, this whole process is just trying to help artists improve.
Your reply was that you have two tails, so that counts as broken.
I pointed out that there's a difference between artistic license and artistic error, and that if broken positioning is defended with two tails being broken as well, then you may as well defend any level of broken with any intentional style decision.
So, just pointing out that "what about...?" is not a defense for a problem, and that there are differences in inaccuracies, where some inaccuracies are fine (these are anthro animals after all) whereas others are just broken despite the artist and character creator not intending it to be broken.
Overall, this whole process is just trying to help artists improve.
Yup. Add it to the list of problems. :P Lack of fur/fur textures have become an epidemic. Everything looks like it's just covered in coloured skin these days. And the stickers people put over fur and call them tattoos. Like, perfect patterns sitting atop (some of 'em are baaaaaad, like literal copy-paste and no blending) coloured ski... damn, I mean fur.
Ugh. His work has gone sooooooooooooooooo down hill. Copy/paste and recolours these days is basically all he does. :( He's settled in to a huge rut like a number of formerly fantastic artists are. Nothing new, unique, or challenging to the artist.
Don't want to badmouth anyways else though so I'll shut up. :)
Don't want to badmouth anyways else though so I'll shut up. :)
Fur is f'ing hard, yo. Though there's at least one artist I know of who openly declares "I treat my characters as having skin so I can give them facial hair." At least integrate the facial hair into the design and don't give them weirdo stubble!
But +1 on those tattoo fails. It's not a dye that goes into the skin and sprouts into the fur like some plant drinking up easter egg water. If it did, the furry tattoo would fade in weeks after shedding. But zero thought goes into it.
But +1 on those tattoo fails. It's not a dye that goes into the skin and sprouts into the fur like some plant drinking up easter egg water. If it did, the furry tattoo would fade in weeks after shedding. But zero thought goes into it.
FA+

Comments