I remember getting one of these things as a kid and being so disappointed. I can't remember which character it was though. :P
These are $6 (or $8 if you want it printed, laminated, clipped + shipped to you!)
Yoshi would taste like creamsicle! :D

art/Yoshi belong to me!
(obviously I didn't come up with ugly character popsicles or the idea to turn them into badges so make one for yourself if you don't want to commission me!)